FOOTYBOT
New York City FC

Kevin O'Toole

Defender · New York City FC · 27 · Ireland

Compare with others

Season score
34.9
MLS 2026, 21 matches
Last 5 weeks
35.1
average of weeks with 60+ minutes
Market value
€1.2M
+€350k (+41%) since 5 Jun 2025
Transfermarkt, 2 Jun 2026
Born
14 Dec 1998
Height
170 cm
Foot
L
Contract until
30 Jun 2029
Wikipedia views
–

Wikipedia Wikidata Transfermarkt

Every week

1–7 Jul 2025 to 20–26 Oct 2026

13 of 69 weeks with 60+ minutes, averaging 35.0 (minutes-weighted); 0 of them 70 or better.

no matchunder 60′under 4545–5555–7070+

Every week as a table
WeekMatchesMinutesScoreExpectedUnderlying
13–19 Oct 2026212245.542.345.4
6–12 Oct 202614533.641.433.5
22–28 Sep 202611014.141.313.9
8–14 Sep 2026211733.841.433.9
1–7 Sep 202619029.842.029.6
25–31 Aug 202612737.341.837.2
18–24 Aug 202629732.041.931.9
11–17 Aug 202613035.041.934.8
21–27 Apr 2026218033.142.533.1
14–20 Apr 202619039.142.739.0
7–13 Apr 202619041.942.541.8
31 Mar – 6 Apr 202619034.542.934.4
17–23 Mar 202619034.943.434.8
10–16 Mar 202619026.645.126.4
3–9 Mar 202619042.945.142.8
24 Feb – 2 Mar 202619021.048.522.9
17–23 Feb 202619039.350.039.7

Against expectation

How it's expected

Each week's score beside what the player's earlier matches led to expect. Over the last 10 weeks with 60+ minutes: −7.4 a week below expectation.

20.030.040.050.017 Feb3 Mar17 Mar7 Apr21 Apr1 Sep13 OctScore 45.5Expected 42.3

Market value

Where these come from
Transfermarkt €1.2M +€350k (+41%) since 5 Jun 2025 2 Jun 2026 · its own valuation, revised a few times a year
Current estimate €1.2M no change recorded 24 Oct 2026 · BSD, seen when squads refresh
Next summer, if it goes like similar cases €717k–€1.2M −25% median of 40 similar past cases; players the same age −18% Closest cases, what their Transfermarkt value then did in a year: Keanu Baccus at 27 (€700k, scoring 34.0) −29%; Godfried Frimpong at 26 (€2.0M, scoring 36.5) −25%; Jeremy Petris at 27 (€2.2M, scoring 38.1) −45%.
0€500K€1.0M€1.5M2023202420252026€1.2M€1.2M
Every value as a table
DateSourceValue
24 Oct 2026Current estimate (BSD)€1.2M
2 Jun 2026Transfermarkt€1.2M
11 Dec 2025Transfermarkt€1.2M
5 Jun 2025Transfermarkt€850k
12 Dec 2024Transfermarkt€850k
13 Jun 2024Transfermarkt€600k
18 Dec 2023Transfermarkt€300k
22 Aug 2023Transfermarkt€300k
8 Nov 2022Transfermarkt€100k
18 Aug 2022Transfermarkt€50k
1 Apr 2022Transfermarkt€50k

Two different estimates, so each is its own line and each change is measured within its own line.

Moves

All transfers
DateMoveFee
11 Jan 2022PrincetonTigers New York CityFree or loan
1 Aug 2021NYRB U-23 PrincetonTigersFree or loan

What the score is made of

MLS 2026: each part per 90 minutes against the average defender in the top five leagues (0), in standard deviations.

  • Shooting −0.31
  • Creating −0.09
  • Progressing −0.17
  • Keeping the ball −1.49
  • Defending −0.46
  • Aerial −0.52
  • Finishing −0.09

Attention

Not linked to a Wikipedia article yet, so no views to show.

Plays most like

same position, last 12 months: the shape of their play, not its level
PlayerRecent scoreValue nowLikeness
Miguel Navarro Colorado Rapids · 2736.4€2.0M97%Compare
Malte Amundsen Columbus Crew · 2834.0€2.5M97%Compare
Daniel Lovitz Nashville SC · 35 · cheaper28.5€310k97%Compare
Jahkeele Marshall-Rutty New York Red Bulls · 2238.2€2.0M97%Compare
John Nelson LA Galaxy · 2834.1€800k96%Compare
Umut Meraş Amed Sportif Faaliyetler · 30 · cheaper36.8€400k96%Compare

Recent score: the last six months. Cheaper: valued at less than 60% of Kevin O'Toole.

Seasons

SeasonCompetitionTeamMatchesMinutesScoreUnderlying
MLS 2026MLSNew York City FC211,43834.935.0

Latest matches

21 since July 2025
DateCompetitionOpponentResultMinGoalsAssistsxGxAScore
17 Oct 2026MLSLos Angeles FCD 1–19000–0.1037.1
14 Oct 2026MLSat Inter Miami CFL 0–23200–0.3469.1
10 Oct 2026MLSat Chicago FireL 1–24500–0.0133.6
26 Sep 2026MLSat Atlanta UnitedD 2–21000–0.0014.1
13 Sep 2026MLSat Real Salt LakeW 2–02000–0.0027.5
10 Sep 2026MLSNew England RevolutionL 1–297000.040.1635.1
4 Sep 2026MLSNashville SCD 0–09000–0.0029.8
29 Aug 2026MLSat Toronto FCD 1–12700–0.0037.3
23 Aug 2026MLSat New England RevolutionD 1–12200–0.0132.1
19 Aug 2026MLSat FC CincinnatiL 1–27500–0.0132.0
All 21 matches
DateCompetitionOpponentResultMinGoalsAssistsxGxAScore
17 Oct 2026MLSLos Angeles FCD 1–19000–0.1037.1
14 Oct 2026MLSat Inter Miami CFL 0–23200–0.3469.1
10 Oct 2026MLSat Chicago FireL 1–24500–0.0133.6
26 Sep 2026MLSat Atlanta UnitedD 2–21000–0.0014.1
13 Sep 2026MLSat Real Salt LakeW 2–02000–0.0027.5
10 Sep 2026MLSNew England RevolutionL 1–297000.040.1635.1
4 Sep 2026MLSNashville SCD 0–09000–0.0029.8
29 Aug 2026MLSat Toronto FCD 1–12700–0.0037.3
23 Aug 2026MLSat New England RevolutionD 1–12200–0.0132.1
19 Aug 2026MLSat FC CincinnatiL 1–27500–0.0132.0
16 Aug 2026MLSPhiladelphia UnionL 2–33000–0.0035.0
25 Apr 2026MLSat CF MontréalL 0–19000–0.0332.7
22 Apr 2026MLSFC CincinnatiD 4–490000.020.1233.6
18 Apr 2026MLSCharlotte FCL 1–29000–0.2139.1
11 Apr 2026MLSat Vancouver WhitecapsL 0–29000–0.0141.9
4 Apr 2026MLSSt.Louis CityD 1–19000–0.1534.5
22 Mar 2026MLSInter Miami CFL 2–39000–0.0234.9
14 Mar 2026MLSColorado RapidsW 3–19000–0.0126.6
7 Mar 2026MLSOrlando City SCW 5–09000–0.1042.9
1 Mar 2026MLSat Philadelphia UnionW 2–190000.280.0121.0
23 Feb 2026MLSat LA GalaxyD 1–190000.070.0339.3